I approach this idea by comparing oecd countries with varying levels of legalization of prostitution against one another. Raymond published in simultaneously in hard copy in journal of trauma practice, 2, 2003. Jul 28, 2015 prostitution is the criminal act of providing, or offering to provide, sexual services in exchange for compensation. New york university press, 2012, isbn 9780814794630. I analyze prostitution policy changes regarding worker rights and health protection for legal. From illicit vice to lawful business argues that current laws simply force the sex economy undergroundplacing hookers in. Legalizing prostitution provides a theoretically grounded comparative analysis of political dynamics, policy outcomes, and redlight landscapes in nations where prostitution has been legalized and regulated by the government, presenting a rich and novel portrait of the multifaceted world of legal sex for sale. Legalization of vice does not put an end to the matter, even when it can be shown that reform has certain benefits, as in the case of medical marijuana. From illicit vice to lawful business in recent years, america has witnessed major trends in the normalization of some types of vice or previously. That seems to be the consensus among readers of our new piece on trafficking in the u. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
Ten reasons for not legalizing prostitution and a legal. Review of ten reasons for not legalizing prostitution and a. While sex work has long been controversial, it has become even more contested over the past decade as laws, policies, and enforcement practices have become more repressive in many nations, partly as a result of the ascendancy of interest groups committed to the total abolition of the sex industry. We argue theoretically that neither legalization nor criminalization can simultaneously protect voluntary prostitutes and unambiguously reduce. Prostitution may be a grubby business, but its not the governments. Justia legal dictionary prostitution and commercialized vice prostitution and commercialized vice the unlawful promotion of or participation in sexual activities for profit. The impact of legalizing prostitution on violent crime. In this view, prostitution must be differentiated from forced prostitution, and feminists should support sex worker activism against abuses by both the sex industry and the legal system.
Some counties in nevada allow prostitution, while others still do in 1967, europe was known for its prostitution, and mainly for its six floor eros center. Prostitution and commercialized vice the unlawful promotion of or participation in sexual activities for profit. Legalised brothels improve the quality of life for people who live and work in areas currently frequented by prostitutes. The bill would provide that for solicitation make solicitation for prostitution, if the person who was solicited was a minor at the time of the offense, and if the defendant knew or should have known that the person who was solicited was a minor at the time of the offense, the violation is offense, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail. Prostitution definition, examples, cases, processes. Should the government collect taxes from prostitution. From illicit vice to lawful business reprint by weitzer, ronald isbn.
Samuel lee petra persson june 27, 2012 abstract the e. This article appeared in the leaders section of the print edition under the headline sex is their business reuse this. From illicit vice to lawful business argues that current laws simply force the sex economy undergroundplacing hookers in greater danger. Criminal law prostitution and commercialized vice justia. For the majority, prostitution has proved very hard to get out of, particularly since many women enter it at a very young age. Legalizing prostitution lowers violence and disease. Using america as a backdrop, weitzer draws on extensive field research in the netherlands, belgium, and germany to illustrate alternatives to americanstyle criminalization of sex workers. From illicit vice to lawful business ronald weitzer takes a comprehensive look at prostitution in a variety of contexts specifically examining the legal structures which make it legal or illegal.
Jan 02, 2014 a 2012 study published in world development, does legalized prostitution increase human trafficking. To solicit customers or transport persons for prostitution purposes. Legalized prostitution as a business takes place in legal brothels within the business industry. From illicit vice to lawful business find, read and cite all the research you need on. Weitzer, criminologist and professor of sociology at george washington university, provides an erudite overview of sex work and detailed case studies of three cities with redlight districts. These 15 countries took a step to legalize prostitution providing sex workers with health and social benefits. From illicit vice to lawful business in recent years, america has witnessed major trends in the normalization of some. Prostitution sex is their business leaders the economist. Legalized brothel business has certain indicators of exploitation that makes the business unethical to practice. Is legalizing prostitution the best way to tackle sex trafficking. Apr 24, 2012 while positive outcomes are by no means automatic or guaranteed, i find that legal, wellregulated prostitution can be superior to blanket criminalization. Yet this folk wisdom is just thata narrow, surface understanding that does not come close to recognizing.
Few activities, apart from prostitution, are criminalized just because money is exchanged. Laws are also in place to punish those who arrange prostitution, or benefit from it in any way. Ronald weitzer is a professor of sociology at george washington university and the author of legalizing prostitution. Dec 01, 2011 legalizing prostitution provides a theoretically grounded comparative analysis of political dynamics, policy outcomes, and redlight landscapes in nations where prostitution has been legalized and regulated by the government, presenting a rich and novel portrait of the multifaceted world of legal sex for sale. Legalizing prostitutionprovides a theoretically grounded comparative analysis of political dynamics, policy outcomes, and redlight landscapes in nations where prostitution has been legalized and regulated by the government, presenting a rich and novel portrait of the multifaceted world of legal sex for sale. Worker rights and health protection for prostitutes. Does legalized prostitution increase human trafficking. Legal establishments, incidentally, constitute only. From illicit vice to lawful business ronald weitzer on. Pro prostitution feminists hold that prostitution and other forms of sex work can be valid choices for women and men who choose to engage in it. In 2012 he published a book on legal prostitution systems, legalizing prostitution. The researchers seoyeong cho of the german institute for economic research, axel dreher of the university of heidelberg and. Legalizing prostitution from illicit vice to lawful business ronald weitzer new york university press 2012 isbn. Prostitution laws penalize those who sell sexual services, as well as those who purchase the services.
From illicit vice to lawful business from illicit vice to lawful business new yorklondon. Legalizing prostitution provides a theoretically grounded comparative analysis of political dynamics, policy outcomes, and redlight landscapes in nations where prostitution has been legalized and regulated by the government, presenting a rich and novel portrait of the multifaceted world of legal sex for saleprovided by publisher. Outshoorn and others published ronald weitzer, legalizing prostitution. Prostitution as a business is unethical because of the sexual violence and danger.
From illicit vice to lawful business find, read and. Brothels can be licensed only in specified areas distant from houses and schools. At one extreme, prostitution or sex work is legal in some places and regarded as a profession, while at the other extreme, it is a crime punishable by death in some other places. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Dec 21, 2012 at the same time, however, several other nations have recently decriminalized prostitution. Produced by johns hopkins university press in collaboration with the sheridan libraries. Feb 17, 2016 the article ten reasons for not legalizing prostitution and a legal response to the demand for prostitution 2003 janice raymond directly lists the reasons and support behind preventing the legalization of prostitution. Prostitution law varies widely from country to country, and between jurisdictions within a country. Prostitution and commercialized vice legal dictionary.
International approaches to decriminalising or legalising. London thomson reuters foundation sex workers in countries where selling or buying sex is illegal are more likely to face violence, not use. Prostitution is legal in some countries, but it isnt illegal in others either. Trafficking in women for forced prostitution is a lucrative business for the pimps and procurers. Legalizing prostitution maps out the current terrain. Legalising prostitution is not the answer julie bindel. Ronald weitzer is professor of sociology at george washington university and author of legalizing prostitution. We show that individuals tends to justify prostitution more in countries where it is legal or regulated and less in countries where it is prohibited. Yet george carlins question in the epigraph above remains apt. Jul 02, 2010 legalising prostitution is not the answer julie bindel an evaluation of swedish law shows that criminalising the purchase, but not the sale, of sex has been a great success. Legalizing prostitution helps cleanup red light districts. As the only state with legal prostitution, nevada is the only place in the u.
1555 137 946 447 1070 55 488 846 657 1322 1441 903 932 1497 1243 1365 1347 24 113 1552 1271 1366 1428 1415 578 1338 802 294 1388 170 1050 726 684 1343 196 165 247